Bigger. Better. Bolder. Inman Connect is heading to San Diego. Join thousands of real estate pros, connect with the power of the Inman Community, and gain insights from hundreds of leading minds shaping the industry. If you’re ready to grow your business and invest in yourself, this is where you need to be. Go BIG in San Diego!
Tenant screening is one of the most critical responsibilities for do-it-yourself landlords, and mistakes can be costly. Missed red flags often lead to unpaid rent, property damage, high turnover, more vacancies, legal disputes or even eviction proceedings. That’s why a surface-level review won’t cut it.
TAKE THE INMAN INTEL SURVEY FOR APRIL
Implementing a five-pronged tenant screening approach that includes background checks, credit reports, criminal reports, eviction reports, and income and asset verification significantly improves the likelihood of selecting the highest-quality tenants.
These tools offer a well-rounded picture of a prospective tenant’s reliability, responsibility and financial stability. Here’s how to put each piece into practice.
Conduct thorough background checks
A background check is your first line of defense in confirming a tenant’s identity and rental history. This includes basic information like full legal name, date of birth, and Social Security number, and details about past addresses, employment records, and landlord references.
When reviewing this information:
- Confirm the tenant has lived where they say they have. Cross-check with public records or a tenant screening report.
- Review employment history to look for long-term stability or unexplained gaps.
- Contact former landlords to ask whether the tenant paid on time, maintained the property and left on good terms.
A complete background check will also flag inconsistencies between what a tenant claims and what the data reveals — such as false employment or fictitious landlords.
Pro tip: Always require a government-issued ID and request the last two years of rental history. Verifying these details helps prevent fraud.
Evaluate credit reports for financial responsibility
Credit history is one of the best indicators of whether a tenant will pay rent on time. But don’t stop at the score — dig into the details.
When reviewing a credit report:
- Look for a history of on-time payments, especially for housing-related bills (like utility accounts).
- Check for high credit card balances, which may signal financial overextension.
- Take note of any bankruptcies, charge-offs or accounts in collections — especially if they are recent.
- Review the number of open lines of credit and the total debt load.
Many landlords use a benchmark — such as a credit score over 600 or 650 — as an initial screen, but it’s essential to interpret scores in context. For example, a young renter with limited credit history might still be financially stable if they have a steady income and no delinquencies.
Pro tip: If you’re unsure about borderline applicants, request a co-signer or additional deposit to offset potential risk.
Review criminal records thoughtfully and compliantly
A criminal background check helps protect your property and neighborhood. But it’s also an area where landlords must tread carefully, ensuring they comply with federal fair housing laws and avoid blanket policies that discriminate.
When conducting a criminal check:
- Use a report that searches national, state and local criminal databases.
- Include searches of sex offender registries and watch lists.
- Evaluate offenses based on recency, severity and relevance to housing. A decades-old nonviolent offense may not be relevant, while a recent conviction for property damage or violence might be disqualifying.
It’s important to apply consistent screening criteria to every applicant. The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) advises landlords to assess whether a criminal record truly poses a risk to people or property.
Pro tip: Document your screening criteria in writing and apply them equally to all applicants to remain compliant and avoid legal trouble.
Examine eviction history in detail
Eviction history is one of the most predictive indicators of future rental issues. A past eviction — especially for nonpayment or lease violations — should trigger further investigation.
When reviewing eviction reports:
- Look at how many evictions appear and over what time span. One older eviction may be forgivable, but multiple recent ones are cause for concern.
- Read the court records when available. Sometimes, an eviction filing never leads to a full eviction judgment.
- Compare reported evictions to references from previous landlords. If there’s a mismatch, that could signal dishonesty.
Eviction databases vary in coverage, so using a nationwide provider gives you the best chance of uncovering records across state lines.
Pro tip: Consider combining eviction checks with reference calls. Ask landlords directly if they ever initiated legal action — even if it didn’t result in formal eviction.
Verify income and asset stability
Even the most responsible tenant can become a late payer if they don’t earn enough to afford the rent. That’s why income and asset verification is essential — not optional.
Standard practices include:
- Requesting recent pay stubs (typically the last two) and a W-2 from the previous tax year.
- Ask for bank statements to assess account balances and spending patterns.
- Ensuring the applicant earns at least 3x the monthly rent — though this can vary by market.
For self-employed or gig economy workers, ask for tax returns (1040s) or 1099 forms and bank statements from a business account. You want to see consistent income, not just one or two high-paying months.
Some platforms offer automated income verification, which links to the applicant’s bank and employment accounts to generate a real-time financial overview. This minimizes the risk of falsified documents and speeds up the process.
Pro tip: Review both income and liquidity. A tenant with a modest income but a large savings balance might be just as qualified as someone with a higher paycheck.
Software can make this process smarter — and easier
DIY landlords often operate without a team, which means time is a precious resource. Managing all five elements of the screening process manually — across email, spreadsheets and PDFs — can be slow, inconsistent and prone to mistakes.
Property management software that centralizes screening reports, automates income verification and provides clear side-by-side applicant comparisons can make the process significantly more efficient. These tools often integrate with national databases and deliver reports directly to your dashboard, allowing you to evaluate tenants faster and more confidently.
You also benefit from built-in workflows that help maintain consistency, reduce errors and ensure compliance with fair housing guidelines — all while keeping costs low by passing report fees to applicants.
Bottom line: The more streamlined your tenant screening process, the more time you save, the fewer mistakes you make and the better tenants you place.
As a landlord, your goal isn’t just to fill a vacancy — it’s to place the right tenant. Applying a five-pronged screening strategy reduces risk, increases stability and protects your rental income.
Whether you manage one property or 10, implementing an innovative, structured screening process is one of the best investments you can make in your real estate business.
Ryan Barone is the co-founder and CEO of RentRedi, an award-winning rental management software that transforms the way landlords and tenants manage their renting experience.
